Fish Bay Hotellit

”Difficult to access with luggage... (a lot of steps to walk up). So it is for a young crowd. Nice views from the top though.”

”Wonderful place to stay. Close to all the shops.”

”At the time the bar was closed for a remodeling in the restaurant, so we left and stayed across the way at the sister hotel.”

”The property is in a great location where you could walk into Cruz Bay for shopping and restaurants. It had all the amenities that you needed.”

”Amazing History | Beautiful Rooms | Delicious Food | Incredibly Personable Staff We absolutely loved this location and would highly recommend staying here—especially when no cruise ships are in port. Shopping and restaurants are just blocks away, along with the (in)famous 99 Steps and Blackbeard's right next door. The views from both the bar and our room were truly breathtaking. While the property still has restoration work ahead, the quality of what has already been completed is outstanding. If...

”Very simple rooms, showing their age. However, the views and ambiance were incredible. Staff is very friendly, and the on-site restaurant served an excellent dinner and breakfast. We'd definitely stay here again!”

”2nd time visiting and staying at same place with overall no complaints, room had same vibe, the few issues that were presented was a can opener and pot handle which was addressed promptly when contacting mgmt with clogged drains as well by maintenance. Parking is sufficient. Had a few other visitors from stray chickens, cats and dogs but no issues. Enjoyed time away from home and explored a little more than last visit. The shopping areas have not fully recovered from hurricanes with a few stores...

”We had a great stay. It exceeded our expectations. Lindsey and Chase treated us as royalty!! Always available and accomodating. Room was cozy, amazing views and accesible by car and just 99 Steps to town!!!”

”We stayed in a 2 bedroom cottage, and we thought the rooms looked very nice. We had an issue with the cottage being warm most of the night as well as the TV not working properly. We reached out to staff, and they didn’t contact us until the next morning, which is when we were leaving. When we vacation, our non-negotiables are clean, comfortable rooms, and unfortunately, the second item wasn’t met. Also important to know that the only walkable food option is their restaurant, which does not...

”Friendly staff, friendly cats, comfortable rooms.”

”Staff were great! Friendly, and willing to let us store our bags in their office hours before check so we could enjoy the day without our luggage”

”Not everything was operational in the apt. Lights/fans etc. but was an awesome place to stay.”

”Angie & Karen (managers) were both very helpful and had the "Pride of Ownership" attitude. The feel was welcoming and quaint. Also, the amenities were great and focused on the guests. I've stayed at many places both for work and personal travel and the staff was great. Highly recommend!!”

”Great place all around!”

”The noice in the area was aweful and all u hear starting at 3 am is roosters it was so annoying I’d never stay there again. Trashy neighborhood also music so loud till late hours then a rooster at 3 am !!!!”

”Wonderful place to stay and Ali the cab driver was also amazing ”

”The property was at a prime, location, cleanliness, and friendly”

”Very close to the beach”