Hermit Island Hotellit

”Loved the view. The room was clean”

”Gentlemen from check in was friendly. Great for an overnight stay . Clean, slightly outdated rooms”

”Room could use a paint job and some deep cleaning. Staff is amazing as is the restaurant which was quite a surprise. Heated pool was great outside room chair are great and relaxing and breakfast was excellent.”

”Hotel had changed names since I booked so was a little confused when I pulled in. Staff was great, very helpful.”

”I’ve stayed here multiple times and always had a great experience — the location alone keeps me coming back. That’s what made this visit so disappointing. The floor in our room was visibly dirty. My daughter walked barefoot and her feet were black. It clearly hadn’t been cleaned properly in some time. Boothbay has limited affordable options, and this place has real potential. But cleanliness isn’t a luxury — it’s a baseline. I hope management takes this seriously, because I’d genuinely like to...

”Ample parking, clean room, friendly staff. Stayed here for a wedding at another venue and it was perfect.”

”Breakfast was amazing, the view from our room was great. When we got there a staff member walked in on us within ten minutes of being in the room which made us a little uncomfortable. As we were leaving the next day a different staff member asked us if we checked out the minute we left out someone went into our room at 9:30am. It felt a bit rushed. The area itself was beautiful and certain staff were wonderful as well.”

”Very accommodating and responsive.”

”Clea”

”Very nice staff and great room.”

”We liked the location, some rooms have a very nice view (ours was not one of them. Very dark with a basement style window facing tire level of the parking lot). Plenty of parking and a very good breakfast/lunch restaurant on site. Road construction made it difficult to access/leave, but that is not the hotel's fault. There was trenching dug around the property, clearly pipe problems, and the hotel smelled "sewery." Our toilet was leaking at the base and would not stop running all day and night....

”great hotel, convenient, clean, quiet, friendly, professional staff, a great place to stay”

”I have stayed in many historic spas/resorts and this one left me disappointed. Staff appeared brand new, were unable to answer basic questions and had no idea how to get the answers. Basic items were non-existent like a directory of services in the room, items to go with the coffee like sugar or stirrers, lighting in the living room area to even read by. They were pushing boat rides but no one could tell us where the boat would go once we paid $30 per person??? I’m hoping it was just the start...

”My only complaint being that our room was by the air filter system, it was so bad our walls shook while it was running and the noise pretty annoying. The pool was amazing, staff lovely and the restaurant was excellent!”

”Vers Nice stay!”

”Delicious dinner. Beautiful ocean view and property grounds”

”Great place & affordable!”

”Excellent visit to Maine and the Squire Tarbox. New owners have made major design improvements and restored the property.”

”Incompetent staff. Unfortunately even if you carry an honor status you can't get room service daily . Even making of bed . Bathrooms need to be wiped down and vacuum daily . Very disappointing . Will stay with Marriott property next time .”