Menemsha Hotellit

”clean room, nice program, good memory”

”Staff when checking in was awesome, room was very clean, it’s a older property could use some updating but fine for the short stay I was there ”

”We came here because of location, reviews and amenities. This location is NOT accommodating at all off season. 1. Restaurant closes without warning. 2.pool closes without warning - cheap towels even for a toddler to dry. 3. Stale breakfast items with no dates, no tea bags, juice machine wasn't working, waffle maker was peeling, no lids for cups. No accessibility to hot water after hrs-machine locked in restaurant. (And they wanted to sell bottled water). 4.Their bathroom soap is horrible....

”The air conditioner was super effective. Always a pleasure to stay at this location”

”Lovely staff, beautiful location!”

”breakfast was ok”

”Very quaint, cute and comfy room. I give it an A+”

”Simple and nice ”

”It was a good place. ”

”Nice location, close to town, shopping, hospital for appointments. Etc. Staff are friendly and helpful. Stayed in one of the jacuzzi. King bed rooms. It was really relaxing and nice, it had been renovated in the fall of 2025. Plus had 1st floor door to the pool area which was nice to get some fresh air and sun. I didn't have time to eat the breakfast this morning, I was in a rush. Sorry.”

”What we liked most about our stay was the staff. They were all very helpful, kind and pleasant.”

”We were not taken care of vis-a-vis check-in. We had to track down the maid to get some answers. We had to get a key from a neighboring restaurant. We tried to call the front desk, we tried to text and ask for the key code to get into our room and nobody ever responded not even after we checked out. Thank God for the maid Susan. The room was shabby: carpet stained, old sink in bathroom weird old shower head. No office to get ice. Still no contact from office. Very unprofessional.”

”Our room was absolutely beautiful, we upgraded to a balcony room and the weather was lovely so ordered take out to eat on the balcony with a few drinks. Ellen was so lovely and made us feel right at home and so welcome, she told us about places to eat locally and things to do in the area. Breakfast was so good, cereal, wee sticks with cheese and ham, yoghurt, boiled eggs, toasted crumpets and lots more 😋 The hotel is so central with everything you could possibly see and do in edgartown right...

”Beautiful view! Very private!”

”Clean, comfortable and good location. Enjoyed our stay. ”

”The room was comfortable and the parking was great. However, if a property advises that it has a pool, then the pool must be available at least some of the time. Because the property also acted as a health club for locals, the pool was never available for us. The pool has a limit of 4 people at one time, which is utterly ridiculous and not in line with pools at other hotels we stayed at locally. Also, there was no signage about this, and we weren't told about this verbally, so we only found...

”Very clean and cozy and comfortable Conveniently located walking distance to anything you needed. Only suggestion is it would have been better to have a ground level room for easier access to the outside with our dog overall ir was very nice 👍 ”

”Wonderful stay at the Pequot! It was our first time in Martha’s Vineyard, and wow we were amazed. This hotel was so adorable and had character. On our first night, there was wine service, snacks and a local musician playing on the porch. Me and my friend sat on the rocky chairs, enjoying the moment and I almost teared up as it was so perfect. ”