Fishers Island Hotellit

”One of the better La Quintas I’ve stayed in but pricey.”

”N:/a”

”Hotel was clean and nice. Staff was very good. Bar and restaurant open late which was nice.”

”Great stay overall, nice big rooms”

”Noise policy was questionable. Awake from 2-5 am because of room next door returning from casino and yelling for 3 hours. Front desk was not helpful. ”

”Clean friendly staff, breakfast was excellent ”

”It was an interesting stay. They were hexagon buildings. The room had a bit of an odor but the beds were comfortable. The shuttle to the casinos was an old limo which was cool. Breakfast was basic, waffles, cereal, bagels & English muffins. The coffee was very good. All in all not a bad stay.”

”Nice hotel, some noise from other rooms but as expected when staying in a hotel:) Jetted tubs in room were so nice, allowed for cheap romantic getaway— a great addition for the price. Will probably come back just for the two person tubs!”

”Decent property for the price. Room was sufficient, clean, and met basic needs. Comfortable budget stay. Staff were friendly and accommodating. Common areas not great. ”

”The room is small but clean. The bed were unconfutable when you toss your body, other person will be disturbed because of the noise and movement. Also don't expect too much for breakfast. It was just bagel, cereals, muffins and English muffins.”

”Decent hotel with good breakfast options. Nice indoor pool.”

”Overall the Inn is very nice. Only additional comment of note is that the bath and sleeping space were nice; but the sleeping space was small, perhaps because it was in the 1st floor location.”

”We had a lovely long weekend stay at this property at the end of March 2025. Our room was a very spacious efficiency. The wifi was good. There was plenty of parking available. We enjoyed being able to walk to nearby restaurants or go to the boardwalk. There is laundry available. There is no fitness area. Highly recommend.”

”We stayed here to kick off our Anniversary Roadtrip through New England. It was a friendly welcome by staff, a decent and comfortable room, and the location was great for the Aquarium and Olde Village. Very walkable and parking is convenient. Room was reasonably priced. Would definitely stay here again”

”Stay was great… hotel just needs upgrades ”

”We were given a room on lower level which was old and smelly. We requested a new room which was better cleanwise. The next day we noticed that the original room was starting to be renovated.There was never any coffee in the coffe station and there was never any staff on the front desk. We were on our own. We have stayed in this hotel before and it was never this bad. We will not stay here again.”