Motellit – Stretch Island

”Fantastic little cabin. Perfect for our needs. Great location right on the water. Such fun watching the seals! Enjoyed meeting our neighbors and hanging by the water. Great price.”

”Very basic motel, but extremely helpful and friendly staff. Rooms were simple but clean and each has a turntable! In the lobby there is a large collection of vinyl that you can borrow. Thanks!”

”I’ve stayed here before. This time on 3rd floor the traffic was louder than when I was on 2nd floor. Oyster Bay is sweet and convenient to the highway. I like the feeling of an older property that is still cared for, family owned.”

”I never felt comfortable here. It’s the kind of place where dudes stand on the railing outside their room and smoke and play music. The exterior needs work and updates. The room was sufficient and clean but I kept waiting for bedbugs and roaches (only the latter appeared). There were dogs outside and barking by 6:45 am. It was cheap and convenient for one night, but I wouldn’t go back. The parking lot was FULL by the end of the day so I guess it’s well received enough to fill up. Your call!”

”If you like the constant smell of weed, this is your place! I inquired and they just said they are not sure which room it is coming from, yet.. Rooms are smoke free 'today', not in the past. Seems there is fair amount permanent State provided residents, Halfway housing and\or other. Breakfast is so/so processed slop. No eggs, no meat, but not worthless. The whole place is pretty run down. I booked for the pool, but was not quite excited once I saw it. I rarely feed the need to write a...

”I actually feel sorry for the girls that work at the desk here. This building is so poorly maintained that the lampshades were literally crumbling into dust in my room. The cigarette burns the animal odors, this is the absolute worst hotel I’ve ever seen in my life and I have stayed in a lot of places that were not good. When they moved me into the second room. I looked at the bedding and found four layers of urine, blood and semen! There was literally a box of chicken nuggets under my...